Car Warranties… Are They Worth It?

car warranties

Buying a car is one of the biggest financial decisions you’ll make, and with it comes the question: Is a car warranty worth it? Some buyers swear by them, while others call them a waste of money. The truth lies somewhere in between—depending on your car, driving habits, and the type of warranty you choose. Let’s break it down.

Checkout extended warranties through Complete Car Warranty  and Endurance Auto Warranty. 

 

 

What Is a Car Warranty?

A car warranty is a contract that covers the cost of repairs for specific vehicle components for a certain period or mileage. It serves as a safety net, ensuring you’re not stuck with an expensive repair bill soon after buying your car. However, not all warranties are created equal, and some can cost more than they save you.

 

There are two main types of warranties:

    1. Manufacturer’s Warranty (Factory Warranty) – Comes with a new car and covers repairs for a set period (e.g., 3 years/36,000 miles).

    2. Extended Warranty (Vehicle Service Contract) – Purchased separately, either from the manufacturer or a third party, extending coverage beyond the factory warranty.

Now, let’s address the real question: Are they worth it?

When a Car Warranty Is Worth It

1. If You Plan to Keep Your Car Long-Term

If you’re planning to drive your car well past the factory warranty period, an extended warranty can protect you from unexpected repair costs. New cars are typically covered for 3 to 5 years, but major repairs (like a transmission or engine failure) often happen later.

According to Consumer Reports, the average car repair cost outside of warranty ranges from $500 to $1,500, with major repairs costing much more. An extended warranty could help you avoid a large out-of-pocket expense.

2. If Your Car Model Has a History of Repairs

Some cars are more reliable than others. Before deciding on a warranty, check reliability ratings from sources like J.D. Power, Kelley Blue Book (KBB), or Consumer Reports. If the model you’re considering has a history of costly issues, a warranty could be a wise investment.

For example, luxury brands like BMW, Audi, and Mercedes-Benz tend to have higher-than-average repair costs once out of warranty. In contrast, brands like Toyota and Honda have strong reliability records, making extended warranties less necessary.

3. If You Can’t Afford a Big Repair Bill

Not everyone has a few thousand dollars set aside for unexpected car repairs. If a major repair could put you in financial trouble, an extended warranty provides peace of mind by spreading the cost over time.

Checkout extended warranties through Complete Car Warranty  and Endurance Auto Warranty. 

 

When a Car Warranty Is NOT Worth It

1. If the Warranty Overlaps With Manufacturer Coverage

Most new cars come with a solid factory warranty (typically 3 years/36,000 miles or more). Some even offer powertrain warranties up to 10 years/100,000 miles (Hyundai, Kia, Mitsubishi).

If an extended warranty starts while the manufacturer’s warranty is still active, you might be paying for redundant coverage.

2. If the Warranty Costs More Than Expected Repairs

Extended warranties can be expensive. According to CARCHEX, a reputable warranty provider, an extended warranty costs between $1,500 and $4,000, depending on coverage and the vehicle.

If your car has a good reliability record, and the average repair cost is lower than the warranty price, it may be better to save that money for future repairs instead.

3. If It’s a Third-Party Warranty With Bad Reviews

Not all warranties are created equal. Third-party warranty companies often make big promises but may deny claims, require you to pay upfront, or have bad customer service.

Before buying any extended warranty, check online reviews on Better Business Bureau (BBB), Trustpilot, or consumer advocacy sites. Avoid companies with a track record of denied claims or bad customer experiences.

 

Which Warranties to Buy and What to Avoid

Best Warranties to Consider

    1. Manufacturer-Backed Extended Warranties – These come directly from the car manufacturer (Toyota, Honda, Ford, etc.), ensuring dealer-approved repairs and no third-party middlemen.

    2. Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) Warranties – If buying a used car, CPO vehicles often come with an extended factory warranty, making them a better value than paying for a separate extended warranty.

    3. Reputable Third-Party Providers – If going with a third-party provider, choose a well-reviewed company like CARCHEX, Endurance, or CarShield, which offer multiple coverage plans.

Warranties to Avoid

    1. Dealer Markups – Dealerships often inflate warranty prices to make extra profit. You can often negotiate or buy coverage directly from the manufacturer at a lower price.

    2. Warranties With Too Many Exclusions – Some extended warranties exclude wear-and-tear items, electronics, or even major powertrain components—making them nearly useless. Read the fine print carefully.

    3. Scam Warranties – If you get an unsolicited call, email, or letter about “urgent” warranty coverage, it’s likely a scam. The FTC warns against these companies, which often take your money without providing real coverage.

       

Final Verdict: Should You Buy a Car Warranty?

✔ Yes, if you plan to keep your car long-term, it has expensive repair risks, or you need financial peace of mind.

❌ No, if your car is reliable, covered under a long factory warranty, or the extended warranty costs more than likely repairs.

At the end of the day, an extended warranty is like insurance—it’s valuable if you need it, but it can be a waste if you don’t. The best approach is to research your car’s reliability, compare warranty costs, and choose a plan that truly protects your investment. 

 

 

 

Sources:

Share the Post:
Responsive Ad

Related Posts